The news “Nanjing University opened
fengshui course” caused serious public attention in 2005, though it had been
claimed later that this course was opened by retired professors of the Nanjing
University and had no legal certificate, this news still set out a heated
discussion about whether fengshui is a feudalistic superstition.
Fengshui,
a traditional Chinese theory about the location of houses and cemeteries, believes
that the location relates to luck and human’s energy, even has an impact on human’s
mental state. The history of fengshui could be traced back to the Warring State
Period of China; and the historical records of fengshui could be found in every
Chinese dynasty. However, modern culture considers fengshui as a feudalistic
superstition because fengshui againsts the materialism and has no strict proofs.
But does fengshui really equal to superstition? In my opinion, fengshui is a
superstitious theory based on a scientific foundation.
The
reason why I said fengshui has a scientific foundation is that fengshui can be
explained by science in many aspects. For example, according to fengshui, the
main door of the house should not directly face kitchen, bathroom or master
bedroom; because it will block good “chi” from entering the house. While the
scientific explanation is that when people entering the house they will carry
various germs with them and if the main door directly faces kitchen, the wind
will blow those germs into kitchen and people will easily fall sick because of
the germ-contaminated food. So do bathroom and master bedroom: people will feel
uncomfortable and disgusted when entering a house with a bathroom straightly
faced; a straightly faced master bedroom will add more danger to the master if
gangsters break into the house. Apart from that, many other fengshui statements
could also be explained by science. So fengshui does have its acceptable scientific
foundation.
However, the ancient Chinese people could not explain those theories
in a scientific way as we do today, so they invented their own way to explain
these theories--- that is fengshui. The ancient people accumulated their
knowledge by observing their lives and hearing experience from older generation.
They summarized their useful experience and knowledge into several terms. But
the point is that their little knowledge could not help them to explain their
results. To explain it and make it more believable, they created their own mystic
and supernatural answer--- fengshui theory. By this way, fengshui became a
widely accepted theory and was passed down from father to son and eventually
became a traditional Chinese culture. So fengshui is just a scientific fact
covered by a superstitious surface.
In the final analysis, fengshui is a superstitious theory based on a
scientific foundation. We cannot simply consider fengshui as a superstition. It
has both scientific and superstitious aspects. The key to dealing with fengshui
centers on selecting the essence and discarding the dross. By doing this, we
can not only conserve ancient people’s intelligence gatherings and our
traditional culture, but also minimize fengshui’s negative effects.
Yes, good girl! Fengshui is the accumulation of experience of our ancesters. Though some of them are not scientific, they can still show our ancesters' creative imagination...
ReplyDeleteI don't think fengshui has a scientific foundation. I think fengshui is based on experience and imagination. The reason why I think fengshui is not as authentic as science is that fengshui is based on imagination while science is based on real objectives in the world. However, I admire ancestors because they can conceive such theories.
ReplyDeleteThanks for stating your point of view at the end.
ReplyDelete